Areas of Focus 

Testimonials

"I have really enjoyed the relationship with those I have worked with at Pinnacle. Our Pinnacle consultant is always willing to share his knowledge and offers innovative solutions."

— Barbara Krogh, Contractors Bonding Ins. Co.

 

 

Overview  — Reinsurance

Reinsurance is insurance for insurance companies. It provides financial protection for the buyer — typically a primary insurance company — by transferring part or all of the risk to another insurer. Reinsurance helps insurance companies protect against large claims, increase their capacity to insure large risks and avoid fluctuations in their results.

A reinsurance transaction involves three parties—a buyer, a seller and their intermediaries. Pinnacle provides actuarial and risk management services to all three sectors and outside third parties such as auditors, regulators and rating agencies.

If you’re a buyer hoping to optimize the value of the your coverage, Pinnacle will help by analyzing your organization’s risk retention levels, comparing costs between coverage options, and evaluating the risk being transferred before and after the transaction.

If you’re a seller seeking a reasonable return on the assumption of risk, our reinsurance pricing model, reserve analysis and capital allocation modeling will provide invaluable support to your underwriters. And as you strive to maintain a high quality and profitable book of business, our experienced consultants can provide the underwriting, product management and auditing support you need.

If you’re an intermediary who wants your clients to be comfortable with the value of their transaction, we can independently review the relative value of competing options. We’ll also conduct risk transfer analyses — an essential feature in documenting the effectiveness of individual reinsurance contracts and a service we routinely provide for a variety of audiences, including auditors.

Experience the Pinnacle Difference: Timely, dependable and professional responses. Plain language that not only communicates our findings, but that adds value in the process. Understandable reports and presentations that help you navigate the jargon-filled process of the insurance business. And a team of experts who are focused on doing whatever it takes to exceed your expectations, time and time again.

Services  — Reinsurance

Arbitration

Pinnacle has several consultants who have appeared as expert witnesses at arbitrations. We are also trained to serve as insurance and reinsurance arbitrators.

Catastrophe Exposure Management

A key aspect of a proper reinsurance program is the management of risk. However, when it comes to controlling your property catastrophe exposure, reinsurance may not be sufficient. Pinnacle can assist you in developing a strategy to mitigate your catastrophe exposure. This may include determining the impact of policy changes, including deductibles, or reviewing geographic areas where exposures are driving your reinsurance purchases. We can develop a strategy to mitigate your catastrophe exposure.

Collateral Negotiations

Pinnacle provides unique qualifications to assist in collateral negotiations. Loss reserve analyses prepared by Pinnacle may be used as a negotiating tool as it relates to the collateral associated with deductible and/or retentions maintained. Our approach is designed to maximize the usefulness of a program’s actual data. Our extensive expertise with alternative markets, self-insured programs and reinsurance provides us with valuable perspectives on the multitude of factors that can impact collateral negotiations.

Higher Confidence Levels

Management often desires to be conservative when setting an accrual for unpaid claims liabilities. Routinely we employ a variety of methods to derive indicated accruals for unpaid claims liabilities at a variety of higher confidence levels to help you assess the potential variability in future loss outcomes. Using evaluation methods to reflect process risk, parameter risk and/or model risk, we can help you find out what you need to know about indicated reserves at specified higher levels of statistical confidence.

Loss Portfolio Transfer

Pinnacle represents the interests of both buyers and sellers of blocks of business. At other times, our independent analysis is used as a reference point between competing valuations of the unpaid claims obligations. Regardless of the viewpoint, our analysis will reflect an independent evaluation of a program’s indicated unpaid claims liabilities often reflecting provisions for the time value of money (i.e., discounting) and uncertainty (risk margins).

Loss Reserve Analyses

Setting a reasonable accrual for unpaid loss and loss adjustment expense obligations is one of the most critical functions of management in preparation of a program’s financials. Performing such analyses is our bread and butter, but emphasis is always placed on using the program’s actual data to the maximum extent possible (rather than relying on external benchmarks) in order to reflect your program’s unique loss characteristics.

When necessary, we will rely on our library of industry, state and insurer/TPA specific benchmarks. These benchmarks allow us to derive reasonable estimates of the accrual for unpaid claims liabilities to the extent your program’s data is not of sufficient volume or reliability to be fully credible for analysis.

You expect your consulting actuary to interact daily with captive managers, auditors, fronting carriers, reinsurers and other service providers, presenting the analysis of the program’s liabilities for unpaid claims – generally the largest item on the Liability side of the balance sheet. Pinnacle leverages its good working relationships with dozens and dozens of service providers, regulators and managers in jurisdictions around the globe to your advantage.

Loss reserve projections generally take one of four forms:

  • Point estimate of mean expected loss and loss expense reserves (i.e., “actuarial central estimate" or best estimate)
  • Reasonable range of indicated loss and loss expense reserves
  • Reserves at a specified higher level of statistical confidence
  • Stochastic forecast of the range of all possible outcomes (i.e., a distribution of potential loss and loss expense reserve estimates)

Loss Reserve Analyses - Ceded Losses / Schedule F

Developing net loss reserves often requires an estimate of ceded loss reserves and distinct knowledge and skills. Pinnacle has the special skills and knowledge to understand the unique nature of various reinsurance treaty types and their potential impact on loss reserve estimates.

Loss Reserve Analyses - Latent Mass Tort Reserving

Lack of data and significant uncertainty are characteristics of latent mass tort reserving. Pinnacle has significant experience in this arena – including both ground-up analyses and benchmark approaches. Pinnacle’s expertise can help you understand the issues surrounding latent mass torts and project loss reserves for these difficult and uncertain exposures.

Loss Reserve Analyses - Reinsurance Reserves

Reinsurance loss reserving requires special skills and knowledge. The reinsurance reserving actuary must understand the unique nature of various reinsurance treaty types and their potential impact on reserve estimates. Pinnacle’s consultants understand reinsurance contract language and have the skill set required to properly evaluate reinsurance loss reserves.

Analysis of a program’s ceded reinsurance reserves can take several forms. A typical loss reserve analysis may first estimate indicated loss and loss adjustment expense reserves on a direct and assumed basis, then separately reviews indicated ceded reserves to determine indicated net reserves by subtraction. Other times, the analysis begins with net data and adds the indicated ceded reserves to develop estimates of amounts on a direct and assumed basis. The reinsurance program may combine elements of quota share, surplus share, excess of loss, aggregate excess, clash and catastrophe coverages.

Pricing Commutations

Commutation pricing often requires an actuarial review of the net present value of the outstanding losses to the treaty. Pinnacle provides extensive experience in reinsurance reserving and treaty analysis needed for commutations pricing. Pinnacle can estimate the value of the commutation and help negotiate the commutation pricing.

Reinsurance Optimization

Pinnacle’s consultants can help you realize your strategic objectives by helping you optimize your reinsurance program. We can provide an independent review of your reinsurance strategies to help you determine if you are meeting your reinsurance objectives -- whether those objectives are surplus relief or cost effectively managing underwriting variability.

Reinsurance Pricing

Pinnacle’s experience and exposure-based pricing models evaluate all property and casualty lines. Our pricing models provide independent cost evaluations of both ceded and assumed reinsurance programs. We also provide additional pricing support during renewal season.

Reinsurance Underwriting Audit Support

Our experience goes beyond typical actuarial functions to risk and product management and underwriting. Pinnacle is uniquely qualified to assist in reinsurance underwriting audits. Many of our consultants have experience as underwriters, risk managers and product managers. In addition, our actuaries have extensive experience using and interpreting the results of vendor catastrophe models. We can help you understand and validate the underlying exposure data used by the catastrophe models ensuring accurate results.

Reinsurance Underwriting Submissions

The reinsurance underwriting submission is one of the primary means of communicating to reinsurers the unique qualities of your company. Pinnacle’s consultants are more than actuaries. Our experience as reinsurance underwriters and product managers will provide valuable insight on best representing your firm to potential reinsurance partners.

Expertise  — Reinsurance

Pinnacle consultants have a tremendous breadth of reinsurance experience. From reinsurance pricing and reserving, to reinsurance underwriting and catastrophe modeling applications, we are reinsurance experts. We provide our clients reserve opinions, reinsurance optimization studies, treaty pricing support and risk transfer analysis. We can help you with all the reinsurance actuarial services you need. Our clients are primary insurance companies, reinsurance companies and audit firms. No matter who you are we strive to learn about your unique business operations and apply our expertise to provide solutions to you problems.

Below is a list of short descriptions of the different types of reinsurance customers we serve:

Primary Companies – Primary companies can be insurance companies, alternative market insurers or self-insured organizations. We can help primary companies optimize reinsurance purchases, evaluate retained risk, review catastrophe exposure and develop reinsurance underwriting submissions.

Reinsurance Companies –The services we provide to reinsurers include loss reserving, latent mass tort loss reserving, reinsurance underwriting and audit support, and reinsurance pricing.
Brokers –We assist brokers by helping their clients optimize reinsurance purchases, evaluate retained risk, review catastrophe exposure and develop their reinsurance underwriting submissions.

Auditors – We provide the actuarial support required to complete an audit. This includes reviewing a company’s held reserves, providing a second opinion on the held reserves, or assisting in the determination of risk transfer in reinsurance contracts.
 
Regulators – We provide the actuarial support required to complete a regulatory review of an insurance company. This includes reviewing a company’s held reserves, providing a second opinion on the held reserves, or assisting in the determination of risk transfer in reinsurance contracts.
 
Government Funds –We can assist you in understanding your potential assessments for residual market pools.

Domestic Companies – We provide a number of Statements of Actuarial Opinion (SAO’s) for reinsurers and primary companies with significant assumed business. We can also assist companies in providing the necessary support to regulatory authorities required in collateral negotiations, commutations or loss portfolio transfers, and reinsurance risk transfer analyses.

Offshore Companies – We have experience with companies in a number of offshore locations. We are a designated “loss reserves specialist” in Bermuda for our Bermuda clients. Further, we provided reinsurance reserve analysis for the Cayman and other Caribbean island based companies. Beyond our regular actuarial services, we can model capital requirements based upon the regulations of the local insurance authorities.

Property Lines – Our consultants have knowledge of the various perils impacting property exposures such as wind, wildland fires, terrorism or mold. Further, our experience includes a strong understanding of property coverages that increase losses, including business interruption and time elements exposures.

Casualty Lines – Our experience includes a number of significant casualty lines, including workers compensation, general liability, medical malpractice and other professional lines of business. We also have significant experience with specific exposures such as asbestos, environmental, construction defect and other latent mass torts.

Underwriting – Our consultants have experience in various insurance functions. They have been reinsurance and primary company actuaries, underwriters and product mangers. This breadth of experience allows us to assist clients beyond the typical actuarial function. We are able to provide support to primary companies in developing their reinsurance underwriting submission. We can also provide reinsurance underwriting audit support, which can include a review of ceding companies adherence to contract provisions or a review of data quality submitted to the reinsurer. 

Products  — Reinsurance

Industry Benchmark Data

Finding quality publicly available industry benchmark data is one of the biggest challenges insurance professionals face. This data can be difficult and expensive to acquire and the analysis necessary to turn the data into meaningful benchmarks requires specific actuarial expertise.

Pinnacle’s client base, especially the scores of captives and thousands of self-insureds we serve, requires that we make a significant investment in all manners of industry benchmark data.

To better serve clients, we have created extensive benchmark datasets with user-friendly interfaces that make our expert data analysis -- and flexible and customizable groupings -- available at the click of a button.

These benchmarks are much more than just data. They include Pinnacle’s expert analysis of the data and user-friendly interfaces to access in flexible and customized groupings.

Our unique benchmarks include:

  • Loss development factors
  • Paid and incurred loss, closed and reported counts and held IBNR in many situations
  • Losses gross and net of reinsurance for insurance companies
  • Custom aggregations of unique industry segments (e.g. trucking companies, lawyers professional liability insurers, non-standard auto insurers)
  • Many custom aggregations with geographic details.
  • Expected and historical loss ratios, often with state and/or insurance company or group detail available
  • Loss distributions by limit for most commercial coverages
  • Benefits on-level factors for workers compensation
  • Trend analyses, including Fast Track Plus
  • Market share and market concentration analyses
  • Underwriting expense analyses, often with state, insurance company or group and custom aggregation available
  • Leading insurer rate levels, class plans and aggregations for many lines and states

 

People  — Reinsurance

Photo Shawna Ackerman FCAS, MAAA Principal and Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 415-692-0937
shawnaa@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Christopher S. Carlson FCAS, MAAA Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 614-734-8366
ccarlson@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Derek W. Freihaut FCAS, MAAA Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 309-807-2313
dfreihaut@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Joseph A. Herbers ACAS, MAAA Managing Principal



Biography
Office Phone: 309-807-2310
jherbers@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Kevin M. Madigan PhD, ACAS, MAAA Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 518-288-0139
kmadigan@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Pete S. Rauner FCAS, MAAA Senior Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 630-457-1296
prauner@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Paul A. Vendetti FCAS, MAAA Senior Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 309-807-2312
pvendetti@pinnacleactuaries.com
Photo Gary C. Wang FCAS, MAAA Consulting Actuary



Biography
Office Phone: 309-807-2331
gwang@pinnacleactuaries.com

Case Studies  — Reinsurance

Asbestos Liabilities

In 2009, Pinnacle provided expert testimony about the evolution of insurance industry asbestos liabilities in an arbitration hearing among several insurance companies and a pool manager. This assignment drew on our knowledge of the history of insurance industry asbestos liabilities, e.g., the evolution of the legal aspects surrounding coverage determinations, the interplay of primary, excess and reinsurance contracts, the history of failed attempts to control the problem and the impact of bankruptcies among other factors. The assignment also drew on our mass tort / latent liability reserving expertise.

Audit Support & Risk Transfer

Pinnacle provides audit support for captive insurers to a major accounting/audit firm. The audit support typically includes a review of the actuarial report and supporting documents to determine if the actuarial report adheres to professional standards and provides a reasonable estimate of held reserves. As part of this support we interact with the actuaries who developed the report in order to answer any relevant questions. Another frequent element of audit support engagements is risk transfer analysis. Pinnacle has developed a state-of-the-art approach to risk transfer modeling; our publications and presentations at industry trade shows have been well received. Ultimately, Pinnacle produces a report with relevant comments and our conclusions that provide the necessary documentation for the auditing firm.

Capital Allocation

A reinsurer wanted to compare technical treaty prices using varying capital allocation methodologies. A Pinnacle actuary assisted in the design of a model that used standard allocation methodologies, capital allocation based on marginal impacts to rating agency required capital, and recent ideas in capital consumption / utility theory. The result was a pricing model that highlighted the sensitivity of expected ROEs to the chosen capital allocation method and allowed underwriters to make more informed decisions.

Portfolio Aggregation

A reinsurer wanted to combine the results of their pricing and reserving models for individual treaties - from diverse lines of business and treaty structures - to produce an annual return distribution for the company. This was a part of their ERM framework and the genesis of their economic capital modeling process. After reviewing treaty wordings and pricing and reserving models, we designed a model that reflected dependency amongst the treaties and produced an annual return distribution. Furthermore, the model was designed to allow users of the model output to easily see how sensitive the results were to the assumed dependency structures.

Reinsurance Loss Reserving

Pinnacle provides a reinsurance reserving analysis to an offshore reinsurer, which includes the year-end Statement of Actuarial Opinion (SAO) to fulfill the offshore regulatory authority’s requirements. We began with quarterly reviews to gather and review all information on newly written reinsurance contracts, including a review of the new contracts to determine unique coverage terms and underlying exposures. Pinnacle also discusses with the company any important events in the prior quarter that may have affected reserves, such as major catastrophes, new major claims, whether individual contracts have paid their limit, and/or any new treaty commutations. Pinnacle’s review provides the company with the quarterly reserve requirements and the necessary SAO for the year end financial reporting.

Reinsurance Price Optimization

Pinnacle was approached by an insurance company to provide an independent review of their reinsurance program. The first step was to review historic ceded premiums and losses by treaty layer to determine the overall reinsurer profitability. Pinnacle then independently priced the existing reinsurance program to benchmark the current market pricing. Finally, Pinnacle provided a cost benefit analysis to help the client determine the optimal retention levels for its insurance program. With this information in hand and our support, our client was able to negotiate better terms for their reinsurance program.

Retention Analysis

Pinnacle was asked by a large self-insured regional transportation authority to assess the impact of increasing their self-insured retentions for both workers compensation and automobile liability. We developed a stochastic simulation analysis, based on the program’s historical claims experience and industry benchmarks, that examined not only the increase in expected losses but the program’s additional potential loss variability. Finally, we discussed with the customer the relationship between their current capital position, as well as the current reinsurance market, to ensure the retention they selected for their program was appropriate for them. The authority ultimately increased their retentions, put some of their excess capital to work, and realized substantial savings in their reinsurance costs.

Publications  — Reinsurance

Links  — Reinsurance

Actuarial - Actuarial Information & Resources
Actuarial - Actuarial Standards Board (ASB)
Actuarial - American Academy of Actuaries
Actuarial - Be An Actuary
Actuarial - Canadian Institute of Actuaries (CIA)
Actuarial - Casualty Actuarial Society (CAS)
Actuarial - Illinois State University – Actuarial Science Department (ISU)
Actuarial - Institute of Actuaries (UK)
Actuarial - International Actuarial Association (IAA)
Actuarial - International Association of Black Actuaries (IABA)
Actuarial - International Network of Actuarial Risk Managers (INARM)
Actuarial - Society of Actuaries (SOA)
Actuarial - The Actuarial Foundation
Association/Captive - Society of Insurance Research (SIR)
Association/Ins - Assoc. of Insurance & Reinsurance Run-Off Co (AIRROC)
Association/Ins - Fl Hurricane Catastrophe Fund (FHCF)
Association/Ins - Reinsurance Association of America (RAA)
Association/Other - AIDA Reinsurance and Ins Arbitration Society (ARIAS)
Association/Other - American Institute of Certified Public Accountants
Association/Other - American Risk and Insurance Association (ARIA)
Association/Other - American Society for Healthcare Risk Management
Association/Other - Insurance Accounting and Systems Association (IASA)
Association/Other - International Assoc of Mediators and Arbitrators (IAMA)
Data/Software - AIR Worldwide (AIR)
Data/Software - Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
Data/Software - EQECAT, Inc.
Data/Software - Insurance Research Council
Data/Software - Marshall & Swift / Boeckh (MSB)
Data/Software - Risk Management Solutions, Inc. (RMS)
News - AM Best
News - Best Wire
News - Business Insurance
News - Insurance Journal
News - Journal of Risk and Insurance
News - Moody’s
News - National Underwriter Property/Casualty News
News - Risk and Insurance Management Society, Inc - Magazine
News - Standard and Poor’s (S&P)
News - The National Underwriter Company
News - Workers’ Comp Executive
News - World Insurance News